I would like to start a topic that we can express our views on which classes had it right and which ones need work in other games. Ill start with EQ1
Shaman - ill start with this since I believe it was the WORST eq1 class. they need the ability to do something besides buff (i know they were excellent buffers).
Summoner -(mage) Perfect class, only issue is OTHER classes mainly warriors needed buffing to compete with them.
Palidin - at least up to popthis class was too weak and not.... holy? enough. I hate to say it but Wow had it more right... probably too strong.
Cleric - perfect.
Warrior - too weak, I dont believe they should be forced to be a tank or nothing. Buff dps maybe?
Ranger - too weak in eq. I belive it should be focused more on the archery aspect as well, less so long tedious kiting. somewhere inbetween eq1 ranger and wow hunter.
rogue- perfect.
monk - perfect.
enchanter - PERFECT please dont touch enchanter.
wizard - Perfect.
druid - good. find a way to make them druidish without being forced to kite so long when soloing.
dire lord- no comparison i gues. I liked SKS